- ID Book
- Dedicated to
- Acknowledgement
- Preface
- Section One Allegiance of Amirul Momineen (a.s.) to Caliphs
- Discourse One Absence of Ali’s Approval to Abu Bakr’s Caliphate
- Discourse Two Efforts to Obtain Imam Ali’s (a.s.) Bay’at after the Prophet’s Demise
- Discourse Two Efforts to Obtain Imam Ali’s (a.s.) Bay’at after the Prophet’s Demise
- Motive of Caliphate in taking Bay’at from Amirul Momineen Ali (a.s.)
- A Look at Historical Proofs and Documents in Sunni Sources
- Conclusion
- Where did the efforts of Emigrants for taking forced Bay’at from Ali end?
- How Sunnis narrate this event?
- Conclusion of the Eight Documents
- Remark
- Final conclusion about attack on Zahra’s house and efforts for taking Bay’at from Amirul Momineen Ali(a.s.)
- Final Conclusion
- Abu Bakr’s Caliphate was always shown by Ali as not rightful.
- Footnote
- Discourse Three Lack of Public Satisfaction from Abu Bakr’s Caliphate
- Discourse Four Efforts to prove the Bay’at was of free choice after Zahra’s martyrdom
- A suspicion
- Cause of Zahra’s wrath against Abu Bakr
- Motive of Sunnis in proving the occurrence of this Bay’at
- In how many ways Sunnis narrate this incident?
- Criticism of Three Standards in Narrations of Sunni Sources Concerning willing Bay’at
- Allegation of Sunni Sect concerning the Bay’at having had taken place because of Murtads cannot be considered reliable
- Investigation of correctness and occurrence of the Battle of Abraq and events following it
- Result
- Continuation of scrutiny about authenticity of Abraq battle and events following it
- Result
- Another look at the case of Apostasy of Arabs
- Conclusion
- Three main outcomes of scrutiny of the issue of Apostasy of Arabs
- On the margins of analysis of issue of apostasy of Arabs
- Last Reminder
- Second standard: Scrutiny into narrations regarding the letter of Ali
- A – 1) Remark about Al-Gharaat
- A – 2) Common points in Narrations of Ibne Qutaibah and Thaqafi
- B) A glance at the incident mentioned in this letter
- B – 1) Outcome
- C) Investigation of credibility of sources mentioned in this letter
- C – 1) Evidences that show deviation in Al-Gharaat
- The signs of interpolation in Evidence 1
- Signs of forgery in Evidence 2
- C – 2) Results of the investigation of above evidences
- D) A look towards inadvertency of Balazari to the contents of the letter of Ali
- Three prime results of scrutiny of Ali’s letter
- On the margin of scrutiny of the letter of Amirul Momineen (a.s.)
- Third standard: Scrutiny of Narrations about the secret meeting of Ali with Abu Bakr
- A) Excuse for compromise with Abu Bakr!
- B) Testimony to the superiority of Abu Bakr!
- C) Caliphate was a bounty that God gave to Abu Bakr!
- D) Accepting that inheritance of Prophet was Sadaqah!
- E) The Prophet preferred Abu Bakr to others!
- Deviated Consequences of Forged Narrations
- What does history say?
- Final conclusion about Bay’at by choice as Sunnis claim
- Footnote
- Section Two Influence of Deviation on Shia Belief of Imamate (Discourse One
- Discourse Two Sunni-inclined interpretations of Imamate and Wilayat
- END Caution of Wilayat and warning of Hazrat Zahra (s.a.) about the beginning of deviation in belief of Imamate
A Victim Lost in Saqifah :Allegiance (Bay’at) of Amirul Momineen Ali (a.s.) to Caliphs contamination of Shia belief in Imamate – Vol. 4
ID Book
Labbaf, Ali,
A Victim Lost in Saqifah/ Ali Labbaf; Translated by Hassan Najafi.-Qum: Ansariyan, 2008.
576 P.
ISBN: 978-964-438-976–8
Original Title: مظلومی گمشده در سقیفه
1. Saqifeh Bani Sa’edeh. 2. Ali ibn Abitaleb, Imam I. 599
– 661 – Proof of Calihpate. I. Najafi, Hasan, Tr.
294.452 BP 223.54 .L3
Dedicated to
Zahra (s.a.) who bore most pains until the moment of her martyrdom because of Saqifah. Fatima Research and Study Group
Acknowledgement
Acknowledgement The Ansariyan Publications would like to express acknowledgement to Syed Athar Rizvi and Dr. Hasan Najafi for their contributions to the translation of this work into English. Acknowledgement The Ansariyan Publications would like to express acknowledgement to Syed Athar Rizvi and Dr. Hasan Najafi for their contributions to the translation of this work into English.
Preface
Preface
By: Ustad Sayyid Muhammad Dhiyabaadi
for the First and Second Editions In His Exalted Name I have read this book with care and attention and found it a collection compiled with a motive emanated from an ardent belief in the fundamentals of Shia school, which is the only clear manifestation of Islam. The great deal of constancy and research is much appreciable, which is further espoused with truth, sincerity and openness in dealing with the doubts by way of evaluation and review. Furthermore, it rises from staunch love and affection to defend the sanctity of divinely ordained authority of Ahle Bayt of Prophet, peace be on them. Regretfully it is being witnessed that there are individuals having long been fed at the widespread table of the Prophet’s Ahle Bayt who are under mandate of reason and religion to strengthen the foundation of the school of those sacred rays of divine throne. However, they have no regard to the bread they have grown upon.
p: 1